Manny and Martin: Policy by exception? – Leonor Magtolis Briones
THE BUSINESS OF GOVERNANCE | LEONOR MAGTOLIS BRIONES | 05/11/2009 12:57 AM
I don’t want to tangle with the diehard fans of Manny and Martin, especially since the former brought honor to the country and the latter is a popular balladeer whom I happen to like. However, the time and energy spent debating on whether these two gentlemen should be exempt from existing policy shows what is wrong with governance in this country.
When celebrities ignore international health protocol
As members of the global community, we cooperate with international protocol on the appropriate steps required to contain the possibility of a pandemic. The responsible institution at the global level is the World Health Organization which tracks the movement of deadly viruses which travel from one country to another. WHO issues advisories on the latest developments in dreaded diseases and recommends appropriate steps to member countries. In unusual circumstances such as the desire of Manny Pacquiao to return home from a country where the feared flu variant has already been tracked, WHO issues advisories on request of governments. Recipients of these advisories generally comply. After all, it is for the protection of the global family.
There should be no debate on whether advisories issued by WHO should be complied with. Yet the entire country spent days furiously debating on whether Manny should come home or not. Manny decided to ignore the advisory, to the delight of his millions of admirers.
The agency most knowledgeable and responsible for implementing health advisories is obviously the Department of Health. Nevertheless, we had the spectacle of the Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources making snide remarks about the efforts of the Secretary of Health to convince Manny to cooperate. Matters of health are the field of expertise of the health secretary . Disparaging remarks by other responsible officials encourage the ordinary citizens to likewise ignore public policy.
Exempting pop idols from the law on the Philippine national anthem.
Debates have been going on about the way pop idols sing the national anthem during mass events like boxing bouts. Unlike most countries, the Philippines has a law specifying the tempo at which the anthem is to be sang. The anthem was originally composed as a march and the law specifies that it should be sang as a march.
Proponents advocating a strict marching tempo for the national anthem have long squirmed, shut their ears, and winced whenever pop singers sing it like a ballad. The singers’ voices crack as they make birit and turn flat as they attempt high notes. They even forget the lyrics of the anthem.
The simmering debate came to a head when Martin Nievera did his personal version of the national anthem. Those who defended Martin insisted that his version was beautiful while critics insisted that it is time to implement the law. I like Martin the singer. I believe, however, that his version is too far out, especially the last part.
The practice of making pop idols sing the national anthem imitates what is being done in countries like the United States. I don’t think they have the same law as ours, though.
Pop singers precisely become idols because they develop their own unique singing style and sing personally-styled versions of musical hits. Thus, they sing the national anthems of their countries in different, individual styles. Sometimes the results are beautiful; oftentimes, anthems are mangled beyond recognition.
Musical artistry and the marching tempo
Defenders say that pop artists have to sing the national anthem with full freedom of expression. Insisting that they sing to a martial tempo will deprive them of individuality and style, they say.
Not so. Any singer worth his salt and his vocal chords can sing a song in martial tempo and still inject his unique voice and personal style. After all, there are many ways of interpreting a marching song. Some portions can be sung softly or loudly. A vocal artist can vary the tones of his voice and convey anger, sadness, joy and courage. He can use his voice to inspire without changing the tempo. Of course, it is very challenging, but that is what artistry is all about.
Try asking several professional singers to render the national anthem in strict martial tempo. For sure, they will sound different and each one will be unique. Give it a try!
Policy by exemption?
Whenever a policy is declared, the immediate reaction is to insist that popular idols, be they boxers, singers, movie stars, and even government officials should be exempted. We have a saying that no one is above the law; yet, we insist that idols may not comply even as they place the health of the country at risk or break a long existing law.
No wonder we demand exemption for government officials from our laws on corruption and accountability!
–> This post is from http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/views-and-analysis/05/10/09/manny-and-martin-policy-exception-leonor-magtolis-briones